Friday, 23 Aug 2019

You are here

Does Your Hospital Staff Include a Donald Trump?

When Donald Trump announced that he was running for president last summer, most people didn't know quite what to think. Was this serious or some sort of publicity stunt? Would he be in the race for more than just a few weeks of intense media spotlight? Would he be able to stand on a stage and debate other politicians? No matter what side of the political spectrum you fall on, hardly anybody would have predicted Donald Trump would be where he is today.

Shortly after Mr. Trump began his improbable run, I wrote a couple of articles about him, and related them back to healthcare. The first article focused on his strong personality and aggressive negotiation skills. The second article discussed the unique appeal of his candidacy.

We are now at a stage where his presidential run has gotten much further along, and he's the undisputed frontrunner for the Republican nomination. As I mentioned in my first article, I was a fan of Donald Trump as an entertainer (I watch "The Apprentice") and I've also read some of his books -- which despite going over the top at times, do actually contain plenty of good advice on winning and chasing success.

I received quite a bit of correspondence and feedback after my blog pieces, getting into Trump's politics -- even though I had specified clearly that my writing wasn't coming from that perspective or some sort of political endorsement. I'm going to say again that what I'm about to write next is just going to focus on his cult of personality and why it can be attractive to some people, relating it in some ways to my experience in hospitals.

After all, every hospital in America probably has personalities on the Trump spectrum, don't they? If you take a step back, it's easy to see their appeal on a personal level. This would be a physician (or perhaps more likely a surgeon!) who is generally seen as one of the hospital "big hitters." They are typically in their 50s or 60s, have their own very successful private practice, and are considered loud and brash in the hospital (not necessarily rude, but definitely a bit of a loud mouth). They can't be controlled and regularly stick their fingers up at administration (the "establishment," who are infuriated that they can't control this physician).

At the same time, they are usually wildly popular with their patients and often friendly and charming in all of their interactions with staff (the patients appreciate their doctor's accessibility, responsiveness, and apparent decisiveness). They will take their residents and students out for nice group dinners after their rotations, do most of the talking, giving them entertaining monologues about their experiences, perspectives, and pearls of wisdom. They will be openly critical of people they don't like in the hospital or believe are full of nonsense (usually administrators), but at the same time be quite sensitive to any criticism and be prone to losing their temper when things don't go right. Some may even use the word mercurial. Generally, however, they are good at commanding the respect of those immediately around them.

All healthcare professionals know a physician like this, right?! Despite being a dying breed in the age of consolidation and mass employment of physicians, they're still around in lots of places. And their appeal is quite obvious because they appear beholden to none, say what they think, and are successful in their careers. Here lies the personal magnetism of a maverick. In fact, these characters still exist much more in healthcare than they do in any other corporate environment, where rebelling against authority is almost unheard of (primarily because private physicians can still boast some autonomy and get their clout from being good at what they do with the support of their happy patients).

To state once again, this is not to get into Donald Trump's politics or views, but merely to highlight how the cult of a strong and independent personality is very compelling on a human level. The question, however, that we must ask, is that while a person like this may be very effective in their own niche -- would they be good in a larger position where the goal is to bring people together and solve complex problems? For our loud and audacious physician for instance, would they be ideally suited to managing the whole hospital if they ever needed to? That's the question to ponder.

Author: Suneel Dhand, an internal medicine physician and author of three books, including Thomas Jefferson: Lessons from a Secret Buddha. He is the founder and director, HealthITImprove, and blogs at his self-titled site, Suneel Dhand. This post appeared on KevinMD.com.

This article is brought to RheumNow by our friends at MedPage Today. It was originally published on March 15, 2016. 

Disclosures: 
The author has no conflicts of interest to disclose related to this subject

Add new comment

More Like This

Rise in Fatty Liver Disease Linked to Obesity and Diabetes

Gut has published population results from NHANES population study showing that the prevalence of fatty liver disease is rising in the US and is driven by obesity and diabetes.

Employed Physicians Outnumber Self-Employed

For the first time in the United States, employed physicians outnumber self-employed physicians, according to a newly updated study on physician practice arrangements by the American Medical Association (AMA). This milestone marks the continuation of a long-term trend that has slowly shifted the distribution of physicians away from ownership of private practices.

 

Dr. Harold E. Paulus (1929-2019)

Dr. Harold “Hal” Paulus lives in the annals of Rheumatology as a major contributor, mentor, researcher and clinical trialist. He passed away last week, one day after his 89th birthday. I met Dr. Paulus as a fellow in 1985, when he easily included me in his discussions and research on rheumatoid arthritis. I admired his easy demeanor, wry humor and every man character. Most remark on his calm recessive and kind personality that was complemented by a body of work that was large, impactful and usually at the cutting edge. Many of Dr. Paulus’ colleagues and friends have contributed their testimonies and fond memories of this great man.

RheumNowLive On Demand: The History of Steroids - Dr. Eric Matteson

A clip from RheumNow Live On Demand. You can access the full library of content from the meeting.

Mourning the Loss of NIAMS Director Stephen Katz, MD, PhD

The following tribute to the late Dr. Steven Katz appeared on the NIH website.